Leanita McClain

Leanita McClain
The Late Leanita "Lea" McClain

Tuesday, October 1, 2013

The African American Woman's Burden



The African American Woman’s Burden

 Old Mr._______ talkin’ trash ‘bout Shug…folks don’t like people being too free.-Celie, from “The Color Purple”

Being in the Divinity School has made me think about my gender more than I have in a very long time because it is mentioned so frequently. We are reminded of gender inclusion and gender neutrality rather consistently but as a Black woman, gender has a different connotation.   Growing up, gender was a constant issue for me because it seemed to be an albatross around my neck.  Everything I wanted to do like climb trees, ride around the neighborhood on my bike, shoot cap guns, and jump off the roof of my grandmother’s house was always prohibited because I was a girl.  Don’t get me wrong, I loved playing with dolls and dressing up in my mother’s and grandmother’s clothes and shoes, sneaking in their makeup collections, and playing with nail polishes as well, but I always felt that the things I did want to do should be dictated by what I felt like doing, that which I felt would be liberating, not my gender.  I just wanted to BE and DO without any restrictions, much like my boy cousins, but my adventures were usually relegated to the porch and front yard because it was not considered proper for a young lady to be running around with a lot of boys.

  One of the first lessons I learned when I reached puberty was that there was a separate set of rules for Black women than there was for white women. White women seemed to fight for the desire to have an individualized identity outside that of being wife or mother, but Black women fought to be acknowledged at all.  I distinctly remember being told, “Black women don’t have the luxury to do what they want to do, they do what they have to do”, many times just to stay alive.  From close observation of my mother and grandmother, I learned that being an African American woman came with an unspoken amount of responsibility to their families, employers, society and the community in which they live. Much like the African American women Canon addressed in Black Womanist Ethics, this often resulted in them putting themselves last, void of affirmation, self-care and self- love.  Because of hundreds of years of exploitation, abuse, and the silencing of Black women’s voices, it is important that African American women love and affirm themselves uncompromisingly as a manner of justice for themselves that they have been denied far too long.

For as long as I can remember, storytelling has been a part of my heritage.  My grandmother told me stories about growing up in the south, being Black in the south, a woman in the south, and about losing her mother at a very young age-an event that would change the course of her life forever.  When her mother died, she was forced to quit school to take car of her father and her siblings.  Although her mother’s dying wish has been that her children, specifically her girls get an education, my great grandfather did not honor this request because educating women was not valued.  I believe one of the greatest misfortunes in life is for a Black woman to grow up without a mother because when there is no one else in the world or even in one’s household to valid them and love them, a mother will be there to do it, passing on what ever knowledge and lessons she learned in life that will help being a woman of color just a little easier. So those stories that were passed seemed to be the canons that governed generations of my family because there was no formal education, but those stories were full of wisdom and love.

One of the first stories my grandmother told me was the story about the death of her mother.  It was something that always had a profound affect on her.   In 1936, her mother died because of the negligence of her white physician who gave her the wrong shot.  My grandmother remember rather vividly the agony her mother went through as her arm began to swell and turn blue as they waited for her to die.  Even more heartbreaking was the fact that nothing happened to the doctor because my great grandmother was Black. Years, later my mother and I found the death certificate online and it clearly indicates that the doctor was at fault, but I guess it goes back to the sentiment that America has had about African American women since slavery, black women were not counted and consider as human beings at all.[1]

The notion that the lives of Black women are the most unloved and devalued human being in society has been a hard pill to swallow.  As I read Dr. Cannon’s book, I realized not much has changed in the way in which society views us.  Even in 2013 we are viewed as overly sexual beings that crave sex inordinately.[2] This is seen in the portrayal of us in TV shows, music videos, and in various forms of media. If we are not overly sexualized we are ridiculed and made fun of in the forms of stereotypes like Madea, Big Momma, and Rasputia, who are portrayed by men, which also plays into the idea that we are either overtly sexualize or genderless.  We are constantly reduced to being defined by our bodies, and nothing else.  Even my great grandmother was reduced to just being a black body, nothing more than a body to be experimented and operated upon, for the purposes of ‘medical education’ and the interest of medical science.[3]

More heartbreaking is that when Black women do rise above the self-hatred they have been indoctrinated with in the form of systematic rape, being seen only as domestics or field hands,[4] and have the moxie to love themselves and understand unapologetically that every life is a reflection of the divinity, the world both Black and white seek to destroy her.

I really thought about this a lot after reading about Zora Neale Hurston and watching The Color Purple.  It wasn’t just white men and women who felt threatened by Hurston’s “free spirit” and self possession, it was Black men as well.  They sought to destroy what was the very essence of who she was:  her ability to tell her story and the story of other women just like her.  The same held true for Sofia in The Color Purple.  Sofia was bold, self-possessed, audacious, and above all she loved herself unapologetically, and because of this her husband sought to “knock” her into what he felt was a woman’s place, which was any position that was not equivalent to his, and because she dared to yield to the role of maid for the mayor’s wife Mrs. Millie, she consumed by a system much akin to slavery.  I also thought about this in terms of Shug Avery, whose behavior was seen so unbecoming to that of a woman’s, she was seen as being somewhat manly.
As I reflect on all that we’ve read, I keep coming back to the question:  who gets to determine how I get to define myself as a Black woman in this day and age and why?  Why must I be defined by others perceptions of who I am?  Even in the academy, I am a ghost who wanders down the halls who is as virtually invisible to my white counterparts as I am to some of my Black male counterparts who feel that ministry (although I don’t want to go into ministry) is “man business”. Or constantly trying to get those who have “othered” me to understand where I am coming from as an African American woman, so I won’t be labeled as an ABW-Angry Black Woman when I am reduced to being nothing more than my wild hair or tattoos as if those are the things that allowed me to be admitted to Vanderbilt.  Or the numerous times when I have been subjected to a bad joke about twerking or asked about twerking because I am assumed to be an expert.   What has been painfully clear is that there are millions of women, some in the Divinity School who go through the same thing I go through or worse, so why are we silent about it?  Why do we not look to seek refuge in each other more than we do, instead of bearing this burden invisibly through a myriad of emotional pain?  

I think that I too have bought into the myth of the strong Black woman and what that entails, but what I have learned is that in a sense it takes away our humanness, which is something we can’t afford to give away because we have so little left.  I have often thought about my role as an educator in an urban high school in Houston, TX where there weren’t many Black women in the classroom and there were so many faces that looked like mine who needed someone to restore, if not give them the dignity they never possessed and I fully understood that my role was not just to teach or get a check, my job was to uplift the black community.[5] 

Now that I am in the academy, I see that I too am looking to those who look like me to help me navigate my way through this process, which operates in the same manner that the world operates towards Black women. I think about people like Dr. Cannon who did not have a support system while she pursued her Masters and PhD.  It is a tedious process, and at times, I wonder if I will make it out sane.  I would like to do a study on Black women and the academy and the how it impacts their physical and mental health, and how they deal with other African American women who come behind them.





[1] Katie G. Cannon, Black Womanist Ethics  (Eugene: Wipf & Stock, 1988),31.
[2] Katie G. Cannon, Black Womanist Ethics  (Eugene: Wipf & Stock, 1988),37.

[3] Hortense Spillers, Black, White, and in Color: Essays on American Literature and Culture  (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2003), 208.

[4] Katie G. Cannon, Black Womanist Ethics  (Eugene: Wipf & Stock, 1988),46.
[5] Katie G. Cannon, Black Womanist Ethics  (Eugene: Wipf & Stock, 1988),48.

7 comments:

  1. Nicole, your assessment of Black Womanist ethics resonated with me after reading your post. I find similarities with you in that my Mother never wanted me to play with boys growing up either - looking back on it I didn't even consider how much that communicated to me that there were a different set of rules for us in comparison to the male sex. But you are completely correct in your assessment. It is amazing how the world begins to effect us with the male normativity before we come of age to rightly identify it. One thing you said in your post about our humanness as Black women ("is something we can’t afford to give away because we have so little left) was a very simple but profound statement for me. I think we often times even take for granted our own humanness as Black women. In other words, because we do carry so much, do so much, care so much, I think we often times morph outwardly into this Queen Sheba/Superwoman while inwardly we are depleted and would like to just have a moment for our own selves. Our humanness is often times GIVEN to so many things, places, and people because it is our identity as Black women to give completely of ourselves. Do you think that we (as Black women who used to be little girls) ever really grow out of the need to have our lives restored of dignity? You spoke of your experience as a teacher and you assert that it was obvious that you needed to pour into those young girls who needed to know that they mattered - how does the evolution into womanhood evolve the childhood need for affirmation? Does it shrink as we get older? Does it transform? Does it ever disappear?

    As it relates to your concern about the dynamics of being a Black woman in the academy, I think it would be interesting to conduct a study on the performance of Black women in Masters and PhD programs in which they have other Black women cohorts or professors compared to ones who are the only Black woman in their class. I wonder what negative or positive effects there are to having a support group of other Black women or if the lack of that type of support would propel one to prove everyone wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for these personal reflections, Nicole. I am learning a lot from your posts about what it's like to be someone other than a white male. As I've mentioned a few times in my posts, to be a white male is to not have to think about race or gender (until you finally realize that you do in fact need to think about it). So I appreciate your willingness to share these reflections. One question I have is about when you say, "I think that I too have bought into the myth of the strong Black woman and what that entails, but what I have learned is that in a sense it takes away our humanness, which is something we can’t afford to give away because we have so little left." This interests me because part of how I read Dr. Cannon is that she is posing a certain strength and creativity and resolve as traits possessed by black women throughout situations of oppression. Perhaps you are referring to something other than what Cannon is writing about, but if not, do you feel that the image of resiliency and strength is limiting? Is it too easy of a reduction? Also, and this is a personal question which you are of course invited not to respond to, but I am wondering about your experience of 'solidarity' or 'community' among black women in the academy. Is there the kind of support that there might not have been when Dr. Cannon was pursuing her degrees? I'd be interested to hear more, if you're willing. But no pressure, of course. Finally, I think a project on the experiences of black women in the academy is a really needed and important project. I don't necessarily have any resources on that, but, since I brought up Angela Davis in my post, I wonder if she has any reflections anywhere about her experiences as an academic (and fugitive!) who was attacked in many ways at the University of California (including by then Governor Reagan!) At any rate, thanks for this post!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, Andrew I was talking about something a little different than Dr. Cannon's assertion. I agree with her 100%! That is what we as African American women do, but sometimes we are scared, we hurt, we feel tired, we cry and are vulnerable. There are times we just don't want to focus on the strength that we possess. Sometimes, we just want to be human, and I feel like many times that is taken from us. There is a support system of solidarity here, but I don't think we utilize it as much as we should sometimes...I definitely am guilty of this. Dr. Cannon went through hell when she was at Union. I know that we have it easy compared to her experience.

      LOL!! I am pretty sure Davis has plenty of resources. I met her in 1997. She is an amazing scholar, activist, and woman!!

      Delete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nicole, I find your post very interesting. I have a few questions for you relating to your family dynamic. I remember times when some of my older aunts and uncles would share moments when they had to skip school to help their father, my grandfather, in the fields with harvesting crops. Do you think that the aforementioned might have been the same instance concerning the situation with your great grandfather and grandmother attending school? What do you feel is the best description of the identity of black women in contemporary America? Can the Black woman have it all (family, career, etc.)? If so, at what cost? I would like for you to study further the dynamic of the "modern", professional black woman as it pertains to her household. I would suggest that the study emphasize her influence as it relates to her relationship with those within her home (i.e. children, spouse).

    ReplyDelete
  5. Yes, I am very aware of the common practice of people in rural areas taking their children out of school to help work the land; however, this was not the case for my family. My great grandfather was considered 'wealthy' for during that time. He owned several acres of land, and as my grandmother put it "they had a carriage when no one colored or otherwise has one". In fact, my grandmother attended Catholic school until her mother died. My great grandfather had workers to work the land. My point is he did not honor his wife's dying wish, and he didn't think education was important for women.

    I purposely did not mention the 'modern' Black woman in terms of having a (family, career, etc.) because I don't think those things define a woman. I think she gets to choose. I think that is part of the problem people had with Zora Neale Hurston. She was seemed to be content without all the things that society says women should want and they made her pay for it in the end. She was punished for carving out her own destiny in the way in which she saw fit. I know many women who are content being single or who are married and do not want children. For many sisters having it all doesn't equal having a family, career, etc. Additionally, I am speaking out of my own beliefs and experiences about how I chose to live my life. I did talk about the modern woman in my own context when I mentioned working in a school with our children and being in the academy. That is my reality.

    I think you pose a very good question about the identity of Black women, but I don't really think I can speak about us as a collective, you know? We are all so different and unique in so many ways. Even in terms of the Black women I have encountered in the academy, all of our stories are different and so are our reasons for coming. I just don't think the identity of Black women is that cut and dry. ;0)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Nicole,
    Thank you for sharing your personal story about your Great Grandmother’s death. That is a terrible loss for your Grandmother and family! I appreciated your sharing on your perspective on the separate set of life rules for white and black women and the truth that black women fight for identity at all. I like that you shared with us that your time within the Academy has brought you to ask the question, “why must I be defined by other’s perceptions of who I am?” Can you recall the moment or experience that led you to begin asking that question and how have the answers to that question evolved? I am sure that your time in the urban high school was meaningful to many young people’s lives. I agree with you that there are so many young people that need to have their dignity restored! Do you believe that you could impact white female youth that are struggling with their dignities and identities in the same way that you ministered to black students? I am a reading tutor at an after school program in west Nashville, all of the children that I spend time with are African American young people. They are deeply wonderful! I often wonder if I could make more of a positive impact on their lives as a mentor if I were not a white female. Do you believe that my white skin may be a boundary for me in my ministry and relationships with black female youth? Thank you for what you shared.

    ReplyDelete